What's new

Opinions on WITCHER

mclovin

Well-Known Member
so i never played the first... i bought the second game in the series literally a year ago. the tutorial is the reason i didn't even give it a second chance. i regret it.

just made it through the prologue of witcher 2, and i'm really freaking happy. i've heard a lot of good things about witcher 3 so im tempted to pull the trigger.

the story so far is great, i just want to know if any of you guys have given this game a go and what your thoughts are.

of course we've all heard how good the 3rd entry in the franchise is... still havent pulled the trigger on it yet.
 
All the Witcher games have great storylines and are immersive. The first one suffered from poor combat commands (it was a timed click thing), the second one felt like an attempt at pre-dark souls era type combat. The third one would definitely be worth the jump though. The graphics alone are beautiful and the combat has been modernized.
 
Since each builds on story lines from the previous game, you really should finish 2 before bothering with 3.
 
so far witcher 2 is really living it up. the storyline is awesome. the combat is a bit different than what i'm used to... not hating on it, just think the learning curve is unnecessary (since you compared it to dark souls)
 
You don't need to play Wicther 1 or 2 to get the story on 3. Witcher 3 does a great job telling the backstory of 1&2.

It's huge, it's like Diablo 3 (loot) and Skyrim (exploration) got together. I feel like it has better lore than Skyrim. Monsters are great. Combat cat be really challenging (to the point of frustrating) but I forget it's not a hack & slash.

Graphics are great, but could be better (almost a sense of borderlands on the landscapes) but the world is immersive and huge. It's fun to go to point to point. Fast travel is good and spaced. You can always call on your horse (pops outta the bush, super convenient)

My gripes: Controls are meant for a controller and it's frustrating on the PC sometimes.
Fall damage is insane.
Pressing E to loot and pressing E to light a fucking candle thats on the stupid loot chest is just like WTF!!! Who decided that mechanic.
Dialogue is slow for trading/merchants.

Those are minor minor issue sof a game that's far more fun and larger than Skyrim!!!!

There's a ton of easter eggs. Choices aren't good/bad sometimes and it makes it seem more realistic. Not really a good-guy/bad-guy scenario. You only choose who dies.

I put 50ish hours already and have barely scraped it. Well worth 60 bucks. I normally don't purchase a lot of games but this one is a purchase. Anywhere from 8-9.5/10, solid, solid solid. + Looking forward to FREE DLC and mods.

edit spelling grammar
 
There are several times, the king you meet on the quest for Ciri and are questioned based on events from 2, most would have zero perspective on their choices. Not the end of the world but the lore does build on what came before. Also, just before your first battle with the Wild Huntsman , you get a tidbit of who they are but just a gloss over. I really enjoy making the choices and knowing my answers are what actually happened in my version of this series.

The stories are woven together nicely and the lore is more focused than what Bethesda has put out with the Elder Scroll series. I like them each for their approach but this version of the Witcher series has brought it up a couple notches with a ton of books, notes and other means to glean the back stories to the towns and places you visit. It has a nice adult approach to everything, this is not a kids game it was definitely designed for more mature audiences and that is something not many have even tried. The voice acting for the numerous Cutscene's (pun intended) are done very well and not overly long and tiresome.

For me, the graphics are stellar, than again I have everything pretty much maxed out at 1440P and it is gorgeous. They use the Nvidia hair tessellation and it is pretty cool, not seen it in any other game and gives the NPC's hair that flowing look that makes it that much more believable.

No doubt, at second to hardest level, this game and it's control set can lead to frustration. I have to keep reminding myself this is not a strictly offensive game and requires planning, avoidance and using your signs properly. Most of the game I have spent fighting mobs a bit higher than myself and solo they are not too bad, in groups they can get deadly quick. Mobs require focus and control to win. Spamming heal pots this game is not. One of the frustrating things is the dead spot around neutral movement, there is this pause when pivoting and moving during battle that is a PITA. Side stepping and rolling behind the mob is the key along with using either the Ard. AXII or even Igni to get the mobs to pause for a better position on them. Hit and run tactics have been working well for me so far.

Fall damage is seriously broken. Running into a camp to attack some cannibals I use their tent that is just staked to the ground and offering a nice ramp for a surprise attack. The fall from the top of the tent to the ground was about eight feet and it killed my lvl 7 toon...

So far have gone through the starter zone and the next, the Southern of the two choices. This second map is huge and has so many things to explore, I like finding the hidden stuff so spend a ton of time looking around. I can see this game taking me quite some time to get through. Also, there are potions later on that will allow you to wipe your skill points to redistribute, good touch and something you usually only see in an MMO.

No doubt, this game is full of what life is more like, a whole lot of gray area when making decisions. The others are pretty easy, cannibals just need to die :-P

Rabbit hunting for meat with the x-bow has kept me busy for a couple hours :-P

For me, I have to give a solid 9.5, the bit of mark down is about the control set around neutral position. It would seem some compromises were made for the PC version as the console search for a controller is on every load of the game. I hope they will patch the fall damage situation, it is a bit absurd at the moment.
 
appreciate the long reviews... i'm stuck on wether to splurge on witcher 3, or batman arkham knight. seriously one of the hardest decisions in my life right now.
 
Top