I haven't decided for sure yet, but I'm probably going with the Droid Incredible 2. AT&T sucks here but I'm still half-considering the no-contract T-Mobile. I read today that they're supposed to lower their rates this week sometime. If that happens then T-Mobile will get a serious looking at. Probably not a gawk...more like a bit of a leer. Your phone ain't shit if it gets no reception everytime you leave the highway.
I've had the same phone for about 5 years. I don't anticipate upgrading to a smart phone anytime soon. My friends laugh because I drive a car with about 200 more HP than I need, yet I don't feel the need for something as practical and useful as a smart phone. Some of the richest people in my city's business community are the same way. They drive $160k AMG Mercedes, Porsches and Jags but bock at the idea of adding another $50/mo to their phone bill for a smart phone.